Practical work in science lessons

Practical work links the physical world to scientific ideas It is really important that science teachers are sceptical about the benefits of practical work. For too long I assumed that practical work in science is good, without necessarily thinking about what learning took place as a result. This isn’t to say that practical work is not important – it is, and I think it sits at the very heart of what science is about as it links the physical world to scientific ideas. Without practical work science is just a collection of ideas without a purpose.

However, this doesn’t mean that every experiment is best performed as a whole class practical. A demonstration may deliver a much clearer understanding of a scientific concept. Similarly, an enquiry-based approach may not be the best forum to bring about conceptual change.

We must also remember that some students don’t enjoy practical work. If done badly, practicals can waste enormous amounts of time, money and reinforce student misconceptions.

Here, Robin Millar considers why practical work is important in science. Do you agree?

Conceptual versus procedural demand

Procedural and conceptual demand in scienceI came across this graph at the National STEM learning centre. Each quadrant represents a possible level of procedural and conceptual demand that a lesson will place on a student. Where do you think each practical sits? How can we modify the conceptual and procedural demands of each practical to match our students? This can involve modifying the practical but think about the role of prior knowledge and skills. The success of a practical is as much about the prior-learning that took place in preparation as it is about the practical lesson itself.

When doing whole-class  practical work we need to make sure that we don’t overwhelm students by introducing conceptually difficult ideas at the same time as teaching procedurally difficult skills. Click on the link for more information on working memory and cognitive load.

A framework to think about practical work

Practical work in science

A useful framework to think about practical work in science is based on the ideas of Woolnough and Allsop (1985). They considered practical work to have one of three purposes. Click on the links below to see more information about each practical purpose.

Further reading